Cyberways: Welcome!
Cyberways: Have questions about what it takes to write a successful screenplay?
Cyberways: How do you make characters interesting or create believable dialogue?
Cyberways: Wonder what you should be doing now to prosper in the future as a screenwriter?
Cyberways: Now you can chat with screenwriter Robin Swicord to get the inside scoop on what it really takes to write a produce-able script.
Cyberways: The chat is about to begin. Start sending your questions now and prepare to explore the world of screenwriting, Hollywood, and the path to become a successful screenplay writer.
Robin Swicord: Hello. This is Robin. Do you have any questions for me?
Janeth Do you have a set schedule for writing?
Robin Swicord: I write first thing in the morning because my mind is clear and I have good energy. When I was first starting to write, I wrote at night because I had to work during the day to support myself, but when I began to make money with my screenplays, I switched to a day schedule. Sometimes when the day hasn't gone well, I sneak back at night for a surprise attack and do a little more writing.
Stacey How do you come up with all your ideas?
Robin Swicord: Ideas come to us through observation and thinking. Something will capture my attention or my imagination and I will find myself thinking about it. Sometimes I will think about it in terms of a story or sometimes I'll have an idea for a character and if I find that I can't stop thinking about these people or this story, I'll begin to make notes and outline a project.
Lori Do you have a website? How much do you use the Internet while writing a screenplay?
Robin Swicord: I don't have a website and I almost never use the Internet for writing. Occasionally I will use it to order a book that relates to my research or sometimes I will search for a piece of information that I'm too lazy to go to the library to find out. Mostly I use my computer for word processing.
JimB What do you love most about being a screenwriter?
Robin Swicord: The wardrobe. That isn't original. Another writer said that, but I've quoted him because it was so truthful! The greatest thing about being a writer is you make your own hours and you don't have to get out of your pajamas.
Speaker Do you find that you've identified with any of the characters you've written about? And if so, which ones?
Robin Swicord: I identify with every character that I write about, even the really mean ones and even the really smart ones and even the really nice ones.
Taker It must have been quite an experience directing for Disney! Can you tell us a bit about it?
Robin Swicord: I was very lucky in that for a brief period of time, Disney decided to encourage writers to direct and they did this by allowing their executives to select a writer and give that writer enough money to make a short film. Gaye Hirsch was kind enough to produce a short film that I had written about my beloved grandmother. The experience of making this film was unmitigated joy, but unfortunately, because of the contractual constraints with Disney, the film cannot be distributed or seen anywhere except at festivals. It was called "The Red Coat" and it starred veteran actress Teresa Wright, who in her youth worked with Hitchcock and Kazan.
Hatter Do you write screenplays adapted from existing stories, or original stories?
Robin Swicord: I'm lucky enough to be able to do both in my career. I just adapted a book called "Mermaids Singing" by Lisa Carey, but I am about to write an original screenplay; a comedy, called "Loco For Lotto." I love adapting other peoples' stories. I feel like an actress inhabiting a role as I try to take on the mindset of the author, but I also love to write the stories that I find rattling around in my head.
Nestle How long does it take you to write a screenplay?
Robin Swicord: The writing usually takes me three or four months, but sometimes I do research for a long time before I begin writing. In "Little Women," I read extensively in 19th century history and letters for about 6 months before I began writing the screenplay.
Rosemary What is it like to be a screenwriter, married to a screenwriter?
Robin Swicord: I'm glad I have the company of someone who understands how difficult it is to work in the business of filmmaking, plus sometimes he and I get to write together, which feels like an extended play date for Nick and for me. I think we are both understanding of each other's special foibles when it comes to needing extra time on a screenplay or being distracted at the dinner table because we are mentally writing. I can't imagine not being married to someone who would understand me so deeply.
Queen What projects are you presently working on?
Robin Swicord: I am preparing to direct the film "Mermaids Singing" and I am continuing to try and get my film "Thing of Beauty" cast and while I am trying to move those two movies forward I am at work on a comedy about a Hollywood couple whose housekeeper wins the lottery.
Madeline What is the biggest obstacle you face in your line of work?
Robin Swicord: It's difficult to get good movies made. It's difficult for anyone to bring high quality work to the screen, but it is especially difficult for women. In any given year, the number of women who get their movies made make up only about 8 percent of the writers who are represented on the screen. Things are getting better for women, but at a glacial pace. It is a problem that is quietly acknowledged in the film business, but is generally not talked about openly.
Trish What was the biggest challenge and greatest accomplishment in your career?
Robin Swicord: I have a feeling I haven't achieved either one of those things.
Victory When you develop a screenplay from a novel, do you ever meet the writer? Is it a great feeling, or awkward?
Robin Swicord: I think I've been extremely fortunate in that Christine Bell, who wrote "The Perez Family," and Alice Hoffman, who wrote the novel "Practical Magic," and Lisa Carey, who wrote "Mermaids Singing," were all generous to me when I called them up and introduced myself as the writer of the movie. Christine Bell took me on a research trip through Cuban Miami. It was tremendously helpful. And Alice Hoffman didn't seem to hold it against me when I moved the setting of her book from a setting in Boston to an island in the Atlantic. I think it can be awkward if the writer of the novel feels competitive with the screenwriter but I have never had that experience. Right now, I am getting notes from Lisa Carey whom I sent the screenplay as soon as I had finished Draft One. I consider the novelist a valuable resource.
Jacke What tips do you have for creating really vibrant characters? Your characters are always so lifelike to me.
Robin Swicord: I hope that's true and I'm flattered that you think so. I watch people all the time. I'm one of those children who never listened when my mother said, "Don't stare." I love human behavior, and when I write my characters, I want them to be like you and me, only much worse or much better or much funnier. I wish I could tell you a shortcut. You just have to observe people and receive them and try to bring your understanding of human beings to the page.
Arow3 What's your favorite currently released movie?
Robin Swicord: I like this question so much better than the usual question "What is your favorite movie?" My favorite movie tends to be the last movie that I've just seen. I think the last movie that I really liked quite a lot was "Traffic." I'm so impressed by the script and also by the fact that the director was also the cinematographer. He used a pseudonym.
Yo Do you have any suggestions on marketing for an unknown?
Robin Swicord: If you mean an unknown writer, the one thing you probably don't want to do is spend a lot of money Xeroxing and mailing your scripts blindly to any agent you see mentioned in Variety. People are always looking for a good script and a good idea. Ideas and well-written screenplays are the currency of the film making business. If you put all your ideas on paper in letter form and send letters to agents asking them if they will read your screenplay, eventually, someone will be intrigued and request that you mail them a copy of the script. It takes a long time to attract someone's attention usually, but you can also enter screenwriting contests where professionals are the judges, usually. The Austin Heart of Film Festival in October has a good screenwriting contest.
Himalaya When you add a character to your screenplay, should you put on the brakes and do a biography of the character first or just let it flow?
Robin Swicord: You are talking to someone who spends several months making notes on character and story before she begins "letting it flow." I am a monster for preparation. Sometimes, while you are making notes about a character or while you are describing certain scenes to yourself dialogue will begin to come to you. It's fine to jot that down, but keep planning until you really feel ready to write. It will save you so much time later, instead of having to write five drafts and getting sick of the project. You will write fewer drafts and rely less on the process of discovery while you are doing the difficult work of crafting scenes. A little discovery along the way every day is good, but there is a lot of discovery that happens in the planning process and for myself, I find that period of planning to be very fruitful.
Alo4 You follow any screenwriting gurus?
Robin Swicord: I don't really know anyone who does. I don't.
Kalsun Who is the one person if any that has inspired you to pursue your career as a screenwriter?
Robin Swicord: I'm lucky in having the support of a wonderful agent. I can't say that she inspired me to pursue my career as a writer, but she has certainly supported me emotionally and given me good advice. I met her in 1980. Her name is Merrily Kane. She is the closest thing to a true literary agent that I have met working in Hollywood.
Bookworm What influences in your childhood help you in your writing today?
Robin Swicord: I was a bookworm too! Reading is the foundation for writing.
Curly What advice would you give to an aspiring young screenwriter?
Robin Swicord: Pull up a chair in front of your computer, your typewriter or your pad of paper and go to work. Do it every day. Don't do it part time. Do it all the time. Sit down and begin to create worlds. There is no other way to go at it.
James I love to write, and find if I am given too much direction and not enough freedom, it just dries up. Is it that way for you? Or are you able to write around someone else's direction easily?
Robin Swicord: I have an inner mantra, which I have kept secret until this very moment. Which is: "Please get out of my way." You have to guard your work from the "help" of others. However, if you are writing for money, the person who is paying you has the right to give you their thoughts. When you agree to write something for someone else, in some sense, they become your collaborator. The difficult thing as an artist writing in a commercial world is to be able to write the things that need to be written while fulfilling the requirements of the job. I find that if I hear the same note or criticism from more than one person, I had better pay attention. Sometimes, the note is only describing the symptom and not the actual problem. It is your job as a writer to diagnose the problem and to listen to others regarding the symptoms when something isn't working quite right. Having to take direction from others, for me, is the greatest argument for giving oneself an adequate period of preparation before beginning to write. The more you know about your characters, the story, your scenes, the tone and the intention of what you are writing, the more you will be able to identify misguided advice later-- in other words, you will know what to ignore.
Bob How did you come up for the idea for Practical Magic?
Robin Swicord: My friend Amy Pascal had taken a job running a new but short-lived studio called Turner Pictures which was later absorbed by Warner Brothers. Amy bought the book and then called me up and asked me if I would adapt it. Unfortunately, after the project moved to Warner Brothers, I lost control of it and I was rewritten by other Warner Brothers employees.
Llauren how old were you when you wrote your first screenplay?
Robin Swicord: My first attempt to write a screenplay was when I was twenty and I made the mistake of showing it to a former English professor, who told me in exquisite detail how very terrible it was. I did not try to write another screenplay until I was 26 and in the intervening years, I wrote two plays, which were on Off Broadway in New York. Through the encouragement of the agent Merrily Kane, who read my plays, I wrote a screenplay called "Stock Cars for Christ," which she sold almost as soon as I had written it.
Lauren do you have a journal that you keep all your writings in?
Robin Swicord: I used to keep a journal for many years. I wrote down all of my precious thoughts. And then I had children. Now I keep notebooks that mostly reflect my thoughts about ongoing projects or things that I would like to be writing.
Dan How do you decide what to do with your story? Does it just happen?
Robin Swicord: I wish that stories could just happen. It would be so easy. Narrative is so important in movies. I think that it is equally important in novels, although there are plenty of novels which have a thin narrative line and rely on other kinds of discursive writing for their artistry. However, stories in movies are "plot driven." What happens next is important. Narrative is something that can be learned, although all kinds of other writing techniques can be learned but possibly not taught. One of the ways that I learned about narrative was through watching videotapes with the sound off. I recommend this as a technique for people interested in editing as well. If you watch a familiar movie with the sound down, the bones of the narrative stand out because you don't get sucked into dialogue or character or humor and you begin to see the secret force of the narrative that pushes through the film. Last year, I reread Aristotle's "Poetics." When I read it in college, I did not understand a tenth of what I was reading. When I read it now, I see that the most simple and basic rule of narrative are laid out.
Mele How much do directors edit/change your screenplays in order to adapt to their idea of a film, and does this bother you when they do?
Robin Swicord: A writer's experience can differ by quite a lot. The director of "Little Women," Gillian Armstrong changed almost nothing in the screenplay, although she did move a scene from the beginning of the film to a little later in the film during the editing process, but on "Practical Magic," my script was almost obliterated by the director's ideas. My husband is having a good experience with Michael Apted, who is shooting Nick's script "Enough." One of the reasons that writers are so adamantly requesting more creative rights in this year's negotiation with the studios is that we feel that movies would be better if writers' work were more respected.
Jim How do you develop the dialogue for different characters and keep each with their own voices and keep it clear in your mind?
Robin Swicord: Again, I think that preparation is the key. If you spend time thinking about these people as being, for instance, individual members in one family, you know that they have their individual ways of expressing themselves or reacting to a problem. The more you see your characters as individuals, and the more unique traits you give them, the more easily they will separate for you. In early or beginning writing, I sometimes see that the writer is more invested in one character-- the "autobiographical" character-- than in the other people in the story. You have to be careful to invest yourself in every one of the characters as if you are on a stage playing each role.
David How do the challenges differ from writing to directing?
Robin Swicord: I have not done enough directing to give you a very good answer, but I don't think from my limited experience that directing is too different from writing; although in writing you are creating something from nothing and in directing, you are trying to guide others into fulfilling what has already been laid out in the script. Directing is an exhausting job because the hours are quite long, and the job involves persuading or coercing people to do the job that you've hired them to do. In writing, the only person you have to boss around is yourself.
Josef Do you ever get to interact with the actors in your scripts? Is that something you enjoy?
Robin Swicord: Writers' contact with actors is usually fairly limited. Actors have a difficult job that requires a great deal of concentration on the set. On the set, they mostly deal with the director, so unless the writer and the director are the same person, there is no reason to speak to an actor. During a relatively short period of time before filming commences, a writer might be consulted during the initial read-through or the rehearsing of scenes. This is true in the theatre as well, although the rehearsal period is much longer.
Cyberways: Robin, thank you so much for joining us! Unfortunately our time is up. Do you have any parting remarks you'd like to say to our audience?
Robin Swicord: Think big! Thank you for inviting me to talk to you. I hope you heard something of value. Don't take all your advice from one person though!
Cyberways: Thank you for joining in this fascinating discussion!
Cyberways: Now that Robin has shared screenwriting tips and her own path to becoming a successful screenwriter, tune in tomorrow for something completely different.
Cyberways: From 9-10am CST on Thursday, April 12, Dr. Glenn Longley, Director of the Edwards Aquifer Research Center, will be discussing water pollution and aquatic biology at www.CyberwaysandWaterways.com!
Cyberways: Please join us and spread the word to others who might have an interest.
Cyberways: This Chat was a production of 4Empowerment and Talk City Marketing Group. Copyright 2001, all rights reserved.
Privacy Policy © Copyright 1999-2006, 4empowerment, All rights reserved.
Cyberways and Waterways is a trademark of 4empowerment and cannot be used without written authorization. There is no implied or express license to use these marks without the express written permission of 4empowerment.